Florida's Shame is Connecticut's Gain

The next time Florida’s Governor tells you that the only way to create private sector jobs is to cut public sector health spending, don’t believe him. 

According to news reports, the Governor’s Office is already warning state health agencies to expect more budget cuts in 2012.  He wants the dollars to implement his 7-7-7 plan to create 700,000 jobs in 7 years.

source: US DOL data, 2011

How’s the plan working out for Florida so far? Dismally, by two different measures.  The first is the 2011 state unemployment claims data.  The second is the story of why Florida just lost another 7,500 jobs in health research.

The 2011 unemployment data show that Florida’s Governor has been more effective at killing jobs than creating them.  The week before Governor Scott took office, 14,139 Floridians lost their jobs and filed new unemployment claims.  In 36 of the 37 weeks since then, the number has been higher than that.  Another 15,713 Floridians filed new unemployment claims during the most recent September week for which data are available. 

To add insult to injury, there was a press conference a thousand miles away in Connecticut last week that explained why Florida’s job creation performance has been so dismal this year. 

 Jackson Laboratory, a Maine-based company, announced that it will build a new, $1.1 billion research lab on University of Connecticut Health Center property in Farmington, Connecticut.  The lab will produce over 661 new research jobs, support 842 construction jobs,  and create an estimated 6,200 spinoff and indirect jobs.

Jackson carries out cutting edge research in the genetics of Alzheimer’s disease, cancer, and diabetes prevention.  Landing the company was a huge victory for Connecticut.  A source close to Connecticut’s Governor reportedly proclaimed that it “will make Connecticut a world leader in the science of genomics.” 

This was all supposed to happen in Florida, as a part of that highly-touted 7-7-7 plan.   But in June, Jackson announced that it had “withdrawn” its request for $100 million from Florida to locate in Sarasota.  In its June release, its Executive Vice President was gracious, but clear, about why it went elsewhere.   “We respect that the state had to make difficult priority decisions in order to balance the budget this year,” he said.  But the lack of dollars “and the uncertainty of future funding made such a venture too speculative to undertake responsibly.”

In a story last week, the Hartford Courant, Connecticut’s newspaper of record, offered up a slightly different, and blunter, quotation from a company official.  It reported that a “Jackson source said ‘politicians in Florida took a dramatic, hard turn to the right, and funding dried up.’"  

One local Florida health leader recently said that “we used to just show ‘em a palm tree” to get people to relocate to Florida from the north.  Apparently, Florida can no longer sell itself to actual job creators on good looks alone.

As a result, the University of Connecticut – instead of the University of South Florida – will reap the benefits of a billion dollars of private investment in one of the most rapidly growing areas of health care.  In return for a $192 million loan and $99 million in support of research, Connecticut, instead of Florida, will get over 7,500 new jobs.

CT News Junkie, an online publication, rubbed it in with a headline article on September 30^thentitled “Florida’s Loss is Connecticut’s Gain.”  In the accompanying photo, Jackson Laboratory CEO Edison Liu is shown holding up a UCONN tee shirt as UConn’s President speaks, flanked by the Speaker of the Connecticut House and the Chairman of her Board of Trustees.

This was supposed to be Florida’s photo op.  But opportunity knocked, and no one answered. 

Florida has only its “hard turn to the right” to blame for the clouds over its horizon.  That’s why over 7,500 jobs will begin to fly north this winter.

Florida should be a leader in health research and treatment, especially research and treatment in diseases affecting an aging population.  But Florida can’t lead when its elected officials are running backwards. 

Florida’s Governor and Legislature have been slashing from health and mental health programs – including public health, Medicaid, and – as it turns out – even economic development spending.  And now the Governor, who should be ashamed by what happened with Jackson, wants to slash some more.   

The next time you visit Farmington, Connecticut, take a good look at where over 7,500 would-be Floridians will be buying their homes, paying their taxes, and spending their money for years to come.  You won’t see a single palm tree.

If you have questions about this column or would like to receive an email notifying you when new Our Health Policy Matters columns are published, email gionfriddopaul@gmail.com.