Veterans Dazed, Not Dazzled, By Mental Health Care

Nearly 2.1 million veterans received mental health care from the Veterans Administration between 2006 and 2010.  According to a Government Accountability Office report released in October, 1.2 million veterans received mental health treatment in 2010 alone.

Almost 30% of the 7.2 million veterans who received treatment from the VA received mental health treatment.  So did 38% of Iraq and Afghanistan (“OEF/OIF”) veterans.  Many more probably needed it. 

The GAO report shows how pervasive mental illness is among veterans, and how co-occurring mental illnesses overwhelm both veterans and their service delivery system.

Younger veterans and reservists are especially affected.

We now have over 22 million living American veterans, but only 4 million served during World War II or the Korean War.  Seven million served during the Vietnam War, and almost 6 million are OEF/OIF veterans. 

OEF/OIF veterans accounted for 12% of all those receiving VA mental health services in 2010, a three-fold increase in just five years.  The GAO said this was expected “because of the nature of OEF/OIF veterans’ military service – veterans of this era typically had intense and frequent deployments.” 

Another October 2011 report entitled Losing the Battle: The Challenge of Military Suicide quantifies the tragic effect of this.  We lost 33 active and reserve duty Army personnel to suicide in July 2011 alone, and veterans – less than 10% of our population – account for 20% of all suicides in America.

There are three reasons why we lose so many veterans to suicide.  They are

• Traumatic brain injury, resulting in disability;
• Chronic pain from bodily injury; and
• Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).

PTSD is far and away the most significant of these reasons.  I wrote about this in an earlier column.  As both the GAO report and the chart accompanying this column show, nearly half of the veterans receiving VA mental health care in 2010 had PTSD.  Most had at least one other mental health diagnosis, too.

It is a national failure that we don’t do a better job of identifying suicide risk factors and intervening earlier.

VA screening protocols may be part of the reason.  The authors of Losing the Battle report that returning veterans have historically been discouraged from admitting to mental health problems as they fill out their post-deployment screening forms.  As a result, the GAO reports the VA now “requires veterans treated in primary care settings to be screened for mental health conditions such as PTSD, depression, substance abuse disorders, as well as a history of military sexual trauma.”

And it turns out that veterans are more dazed than dazzled by the mental health care they are offered.

They avoid it, the VA told the GAO, because of stigma, lack of understanding about available services, logistical challenges accessing health services, and concerns about the quality of VA care.

• Mental illnesses are stigmatizing largely because many people still believe that they are “behavioral” weaknesses, not serious and life-threatening diseases that can shorten life expectancy by 25 years.
• Many also believe that services are only for people who are severely mentally ill.  They avoid seeking care for fear they will be labeled “whiners” and “psychosomatics.”
• Veterans, reservists, and non-veterans have logistical challenges in accessing services.  The VA does not have a full complement of mental health providers.  At least those they have get paid.  Major insurance companies are cutting reimbursements to community mental health providers, so patients who find providers outside of the VA often can no longer afford the out-of-pocket cost.
• It is impossible to have a quality mental health care system unless non-mental health professionals don’t just screen for – but are trained in managing – mental illnesses.

A 2009 SAMSHA reportfound similar reasons given by the 5.1 million civilians who also reported unmet mental health needs.

We can begin to fix this if we do four things:

1. Commit a fraction of the resources we committed to the wars to fight the mental illnesses they have caused – in the VA and in the community, wherever veterans, reservists, and non-veterans receive services.
2. Increase training of primary and specialty care providers so they recognize, diagnose, manage, and refer patients with mental illnesses.
3. Make periodic mental health screening a part of wellness exams for everyone, starting with young children.
4. Insist that insurers honor the mental health parity mandate.

We remember the sacrifices of our veterans when we fly our flag.  We honor those sacrifices when we take care of the men and women who made them.

Many organizations now link to Our Health Policy Matters columns.  Links are free of charge and can increase readership for both sites.  If you know of an organization you think would like to link to OHPM, please email gionfriddopaul@gmail.com.